Skip to content

Rising CPCs in Paid Search: Should You be Worried?

If you run paid search campaigns and you have not noticed your cost-per-click rising over the last year or so, you are either in a very unusual market category or you have not been looking closely enough. The shift is real, it is measurable, and it is directly connected to everything that is happening with AI overviews, AI mode, and the broader reshaping of how people interact with Google.

But here is the thing: rising CPCs do not automatically mean your paid search strategy is broken. And the commentary that has followed some of the more alarming headline figures, including the suggestion that paid search is entering a terminal decline, that the click is dying, that brands should start redirecting their budgets elsewhere, is, for most businesses, the wrong conclusion to draw from the data.

What is actually driving the increase in CPCs?

Two things are happening simultaneously, and they are connected. The first is that AI overviews and AI mode are absorbing more of the search results page. Around half of all search queries now return some form of AI-generated result prominently, and the figure is climbing. In categories like healthcare and finance, it is already approaching 90%. That shift takes up real estate that was previously available to organic listings and, increasingly, to paid ads. There is simply less space on the page to compete for.

The second is the zero-click effect. In Google's AI mode, the fully conversational chatbot-style experience that now has over a billion monthly users, around 92% of users do not click through anywhere after getting their answer. That is a profound change to the economic model that has underpinned paid search for the past two decades. Fewer clicks means fewer opportunities to bid on, and basic supply and demand does the rest: costs go up.

"AI mode now has over a billion monthly users. Around 92% of those users do not click through anywhere after getting their answer. That is a profound change to the economic model that has underpinned paid search for two decades."

Google's response to all of this, though, is instructive. Their search advertising revenues continue to grow. Not because the click problem is not real, but because Google has every commercial incentive to protect those revenues, and they are doing so by making the remaining inventory more valuable and by introducing new ad placements into the AI experience itself through Performance Max and AI Max.

For advertisers, that means the market is getting more competitive. More competition for fewer clicks equals higher CPCs.

Why this does not have to be a crisis

Here is the part that tends to get lost in the noise: the clicks that survive in this new environment are worth more.

Think about what it means for someone to see an AI overview, read a detailed, synthesised answer to their question, and still click through to a website. They have already moved past the research phase. They are not clicking because they need to find out whether your product or service exists. They are clicking because they have made a decision, or they are very close to making one. The intent baked into that click is significantly higher than it was when search was an earlier-stage discovery tool.

At Mentor, we are seeing this play out in the data. Higher CPCs, yes. But in many cases, higher conversion rates too. If you are paying 50% more per click but converting at a rate that is 50% higher, your cost per conversion has not moved. And cost per conversion, not CPC in isolation, is the metric that should be governing your decisions.

“The clicks that survive are worth more. The intent baked into a post-AI-overview click is significantly higher than it was when search was an earlier-stage discovery tool.”

Before you draw any conclusions from a rising CPC figure, check what is happening to your conversion rate and your cost per conversion. If those metrics are holding steady or improving, the headline CPC number is telling you less than you might think.

Five things to do before you start worrying

If your cost per conversion is genuinely deteriorating, or if you want to make sure you are as well-positioned as possible for the environment we are now operating in, there are five areas that consistently make the difference.

Fix your tracking

If your tracking is incomplete or unreliable, the AI systems that now govern much of how paid campaigns are optimised are working with bad data, and they will make bad decisions as a result. Quality of data is no longer a nice-to-have; it is the foundation everything else is built on.

Negative keywords have positive outcomes

A few years ago, negatives were a housekeeping task, something you tended to periodically and did not lose sleep over. In a world where AI campaigns are making increasingly autonomous decisions about when and where to show your ads, negatives are one of the primary tools you have to guide that AI and keep spend focused on the terms that actually convert for you.

Make sure landing pages are on point

The higher intent of the post-AI-overview click means that when someone does arrive on your site, they are ready to make a decision. Meeting them with a landing page that is cluttered, slow, or unclear is a particularly expensive mistake in this context.

Take pride in your product feeds

In an environment where your product listings are increasingly being surfaced by AI systems based on the data you have provided, the richness and accuracy of that feed is directly linked to the visibility you achieve.

Diversify your paid media mix

If paid search currently carries a disproportionate share of your digital marketing budget, the current environment is a good reason to revisit that. Not to abandon search, but to ensure you are not over-exposed to a single channel at a moment when its dynamics are shifting.

The bigger picture

The death of paid search has been predicted many times over the last twenty years. It has not died yet, and it is not about to. What is happening is a significant structural shift that requires a different kind of attention and a more sophisticated understanding of the metrics that actually matter. The businesses that navigate it well will be the ones that resist the temptation to react to headlines and instead focus on the data that tells the real story of their campaigns.

If you would like to talk through what the current landscape means for your paid search strategy, or get an honest assessment of whether your campaigns are set up to perform in the environment we are now in, we would be delighted to help. Get in touch with our team to start the conversation.